6/18/2024

Comparing Maturity of Pioneer® Brand Corn Products

Corn leaves in wind - midseason - closeup

Field Facts
Written by Mark Jeschke, Ph.D., Pioneer Agronomy Manager

Key Points

  • Comparative relative maturity (CRM) ratings are values that allow maturity comparisons between corn products.
  • There is no industry standard for maturity ratings, which can make it challenging to compare corn product maturities across seed brands.
  • CRM rating is based on expected grain moisture at harvest – each additional in point in CRM reflects an additional ½ point of moisture at the same harvest timing.
  • Hybrids with the same CRM rating may differ in their time to silking and physiological maturity.
  • Understanding the time to silking and physiological maturity is important for mitigating stress risk, managing irrigation timing, and ensuring hybrids can reach maturity before the first frost.

Comparative Relative Maturity (CRM)

Corn maturity ratings help growers compare and select corn products, manage risk, and spread out their harvest period. However, because there is no industry standard for these ratings, comparing corn product maturities across seed brands is not necessarily straightforward. This Field Facts explains corn maturation and the comparative relative maturity (CRM) rating system for Pioneer® brand corn products.

By rating its corn products for silking, physiological maturity and harvest moisture, Corteva Agriscience provides information needed to accurately compare corn product differences and help make sound decisions. CRM ratings for Pioneer brand corn products are values that allow maturity comparisons between corn products. However, they do not represent actual days from planting or emergence. Because growers tend to talk in calendar days, the guidelines provided here will allow you to convert CRM or growing degree unit (GDU) differences between corn products to approximate calendar days. Varied climates or extreme conditions may alter some corn maturity comparisons.

Growing Degree Units (GDU)

Growing degree unit ratings assigned to Pioneer brand corn products are based on the amount of heat unit accumulation measured from planting date to silk and physiological maturity (or zero kernel milk line), using the 50°F minimum / 86°F maximum accumulation method.

The GDU formula to calculate daily accumulation is:

GDUs = [(min. temp. ≥ 50°F + max. temp. ≤ 86°F) / 2] – 50

Progression of the milkline down the kernels as corn ears approach physiological maturity

Progression of the milkline down the kernels as corn ears approach physiological maturity

Figure 1. Progression of the milkline down the kernels as corn ears approach physiological maturity.

GDUs, like relative maturity ratings, have no industry standard. Companies use different formulas or methods to calculate GDUs and evaluate their corn products in different locations, so comparisons between companies are usually difficult.

GDUs to physiological maturity (zero kernel milk line), is the best indicator to determine if a corn product can normally mature in an area based on comparison with long-term GDU accumulation records for the area.

Comparing Maturity Differences at Silking

Some growers like to spread the pollination period to help reduce risk of yield loss associated with stress events during this time, but planting corn products with different harvest moisture ratings (different maturities) may not always provide the desired difference. These general guidelines can help:

  • At silking, a difference between corn product ratings of 25 GDUs equals approximately one calendar day.
  • Under normal planting conditions, a 5-day delay in planting date equals only a 2-day delay in silking date.

Example: Similar harvest moisture w/ different silking dates:

Hybrid GDU's to Silk CRM
Hybrid A 1240 100
Hybrid B 1190 100
Difference 50 GDU's   0 CRM
Guideline 25 GDU = -1 day 1 CRM = -1 day
Calendar Day Difference 2 days 0 days

Hybrid B will silk around two days earlier than Hybrid A.

Example: Different harvest moisture but similar silking dates:

Hybrid GDUs to Silk CRM
Hybrid C 1340 109
Hybrid D 1340 111
Difference 0 GDUs   2 CRM
Calendar Day Difference 0 days 2 days

Even though Hybrid D is two days later to harvest moisture, Hybrid C and Hybrid D will silk at about the same time.

Research has documented that corn can adjust its growth and development, requiring fewer GDUs to reach maturity when planted later. For example, if Hybrid C were planted on May 1 and again on May 20, instead of an 8- to 10-day delay in silking, you may observe only a 4- to 5-day difference.

Area Adaptation – To help determine if a new corn product fits your area, compare its silk rating to a corn product you know and consider these general guidelines:

  • Earlier silking corn products generally move north of their adapted zone and more readily adapt to higher elevations.
  • If moved too far north or up in elevation, late silking corn products may not reach physiological maturity before frost or may have reduced yield potential if abnormally late silking exposes the crop to cooler temperatures during grain fill.

Early Irrigation Timing – Corn products that silk early should receive irrigation earlier than those that silk late. The first in season irrigation of early corn products, planted south of their normal adapted zone for early harvest, should be based on their stage of development rather than traditional calendar dates that may be used for full-season corn products.

US map showing dominant corn maturity zones

Figure 2. Dominant corn maturity zones. Click here or on the image above for a larger view.

Stress during the period spanning two weeks before until two weeks after silking can result in large yield reductions since kernel number is determined during this stage. Severe moisture stress can delay silk emergence, reduce kernel set and cause incomplete pollination.

Comparing Differences at Physiological Maturity

A hard killing frost before physiological maturity will cause premature black layer, halt grain fill, and may result in poor grain quality and test weight. Frost-damaged corn is usually slower drying and additional losses may result due to delayed harvest. It is critical to select corn products that can normally mature before the first average killing frost date in your area.

The GDUs to physiological maturity rating is the best indicator to determine whether a corn product can safely be planted in an area. Compare the ratings of a new or unfamiliar corn product to one you are currently planting or one that is used successfully in your area.

Example: Corn products with similar harvest moisture or CRM in the fall can reach physiological maturity at different times:

Hybrid GDUs to Phys. Maturity CRM
Hybrid E 2580 111
Hybrid F 2730 111
Difference 150 GDUs   0 CRM
Guideline 15 GDU = -1 day 1 CRM = -1 day
Calendar Day Difference 10 days 0 days

Hybrid E will reach physiological maturity about 10 days earlier than Hybrid F.

General Guidelines:

  • At physiological maturity (zero milk line), a difference between corn product ratings of 15 GDUs equals approximately one calendar day.
  • At physiological maturity (zero milk line), the grain moisture content will be approximately 30 percent for most corn products.

Final Irrigation Timing – Late season stress can reduce yields due to premature death by reducing kernel weight and inviting stalk rot problems. Grain quality and test weight can also be significantly affected.

Several different methods or models exist to calculate final irrigation needs. Comparing GDU differences between corn products for physiological maturity and checking for zero milk line development in the field can be helpful general indicators of final water requirements.

Example: A corn product that reaches physiological maturity early shows that its kernel milk line is almost completely down and approaching black layer. If your field water-holding capacity is at 60%, further irrigation may not be required. However, a corn product that is 5 to 10 days later to physiological maturity may require an additional watering to mature properly, depending on field capacity or daily water use.

Comparing Maturity Differences at Harvest

By comparing harvest moisture (CRM) ratings, you can estimate the difference in moisture content between corn products and help plan a harvest schedule. A corn product with a CRM difference of 10 would be approximately 10 days later to reach a similar harvest moisture level (normally in the low 20s) if planted on the same date as the earlier corn product.

By using the general guideline that one CRM equals ½ point of moisture, a corn product that is rated 10 CRM later would be approximately 5 points wetter if both corn products were planted and harvested the same day. In the field, however, this relationship can change depending on harvest timing, moisture at harvest and environmental conditions.



The foregoing is provided for informational use only. Please contact your Pioneer sales professional for information and suggestions specific to your operation. Product performance is variable and depends on many factors such as moisture and heat stress, soil type, management practices and environmental stress as well as disease and pest pressures. Individual results may vary.

Pioneer® brand products are provided subject to the terms and conditions of purchase which are part of the labeling and purchase documents.